Not getting proper response in slot connected with QNetworkAccessManager second time

Hi All,

I am working on BB10 native extension which is written in QT. I have started a thread to execute my network request.

Code:

---

void* SignalThread(void* parent) {
	TemplateJS *pParent = static_cast<TemplateJS *>(parent);
 
    int argc = 0;
    char **argv = NULL;
    QCoreApplication QCoreApplication(argc, argv);
    webworks::TemplateNDK *m_signalHandler = new webworks::TemplateNDK(pParent);
    m_signalHandler->doNetworkRequest(); //sending network request
 
    QCoreApplication::exec();
 
    delete m_signalHandler;
    return NULL;
}
 
 
bool TemplateJS::StartThread(){
 
    pthread_attr_t thread_attr;
    pthread_attr_init(&thread_attr);
    pthread_attr_setdetachstate(&thread_attr, PTHREAD_CREATE_DETACHED);
 
    pthread_t m_thread;
    pthread_create(&m_thread, &thread_attr, SignalThread, static_cast<void *>(this));
    pthread_attr_destroy(&thread_attr);
    if (!m_thread) {
        return true;
    } else {
        return false;
    }
}

---

Here is my simple code to start request.

Code:

---

void TemplateNDK::doNetworkRequest()
    {
        _networkAccessManager = new QNetworkAccessManager();
 
        QObject::connect(_networkAccessManager, SIGNAL(finished(QNetworkReply*)), this,
                SLOT(onRequestFinished(QNetworkReply*)));
 
        QNetworkRequest request = QNetworkRequest();
        QString inputUrl = QString::fromUtf8(url.c_str());
        request.setUrl(QUrl(inputUrl));
        QNetworkReply* response = _networkAccessManager->get(request);
}

---

When i call startThread() function first time slot returns proper response. But when I call same startThread() function second time it stuck and does not execute slot. QObject::connect is returning true both times.

If using QTimer to abort request after interval then second time onRequestFinished slot is getting executed and returns value of reply->error() as 5 that is "operation canceled".

Am i doing something wrong with QCoreApplication::exec().
Please help.

Thanks.

Never seen exec() being called without object, you better call exec() on the QCoreApplication object that you created.

The code should be somewhat like this

Code:

---

QCoreApplication app(....);
 
// setup stuff
 
app.exec();

---

I wonder what you are doing here though.
This is obviously intended to be used by a non-Qt application. BB10's app framework "Cascades" is Qt4 based. Kind of a strange conflict.

Cheers,
_

This code is being used for BB10 native extension which is not fully cascades app. Referring below URL for implementation:

https://github.com/haahmad/SignalSlo...gnalSlotJS.cpp

Tried what you suggested to call exec() function using object. But it seems to be not working. In this case, got response successfully for the first time but app stuck somewhere and does not return even after time out.

Also tried to connect signal slot with QNetworkReply object instead of QNetworkAccessManager object as suggested in some posts. But this is also not working even for the first time.

Thanks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BB_Shi

Tried what you suggested to call exec() function using object. But it seems to be not working. In this case, got response successfully for the first time but app stuck somewhere and does not return even after time out.

---

Did you connect anything to the application's quit() slot or call it after you are done with the request?

Alternatively keep the thread running and send new request into it instead of creating and destroying it every time and having to make sure that only one such thread ever exists at the same time?

Cheers,
_

I tried to call QCoreApplication::quit() and application terminated at that point.

I will try alternative method also.

Thanks.

Quote:

---

QCoreApplication QCoreApplication(argc, argv);

---

I hope this is just a bad cut and paste job, because I have no idea what you intend this line of code to do.

I am not finding any way to create thread only once and send request in already running thread because the function which is calling pthread_create needs to be called by below function. Calling of this function can't be handled. This function is called every time whenever a button is clicked from javascript application.

Code:

---

string TemplateJS::InvokeMethod(const string& command) {
	// command appears with parameters following after a space
	int index = command.find_first_of(" ");
	std::string strCommand = command.substr(0, index);
	std::string arg = command.substr(index + 1, command.length());
	params = arg;
	if (strCommand == "request") {
		StartThread();
 
		strCommand.append(";");
		strCommand.append(command);
		return strCommand;
	}
 
	return "Unknown C++ method";
}

---

if I call m_signalHandler->doNetworkRequest(); two times in SignalThread then it's working fine and returns good response. But if I call StartThread() two times in above function, app exits.

---

Added after 10 minutes:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by d_stranz

I hope this is just a bad cut and paste job, because I have no idea what you intend this line of code to do.

---

I have changed it to

Code:

---

QCoreApplication app(argc, argv);

---

Also according to document since exec() is static function of QCoreApplication so it can be called like: QCoreApplication::exec();

Please correct me if something is wrong. As I am new to this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BB_Shi

I am not finding any way to create thread only once and send request in already running thread because the function which is calling pthread_create needs to be called by below function.

---

You would of course only call the setup function once.

Once the thread and its event loop are running, you have a couple of options to send the requests:
- QCoreApplication::postEvent and a custom event sent to your worker object.
- Or letting the worker object block on a semaphore or wait condition and doing traditional cross-thread data handover.
- Might even work to do QMetaObject::invokeMethod on the worker object (using a Qt::QueuedConnection type)

Cheers,
_

I am new to this. Can you please provide any sample code that can help.

---

Added after 1 38 minutes:

Is there any way to find out number of threads running in an application?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BB_Shi

I am new to this. Can you please provide any sample code that can help.

---

For the first option create a subclass of QEvent.
For the second option have a look at QWaitCondition or QSemphore.
For the third option have a look at QMetaObject::invokeMethod()

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BB_Shi

Is there any way to find out number of threads running in an application?

---

There might be operating system specific API for this.

Cheers,
_