very strange behaviour

[regix]

Hi,

I'm develloping a GPL application and for the last weeks I have noticed a very strange behaviour of my application. I'm using kdevelop to write the code.
I have added a screenshot of the strange fact that although during the debuggingsession you can see tha the value of the variable is false, during testing in an if construction, execution goes on inside the if construction. It's a pity that I can't post a bigger screenshot (limitations of this forum).
What is going on, the laws of physics seem broken.

Regix

[wysota]

Did you check the value during runtime? Maybe there it is true and not false? Maybe you have some uninitialised variable somewhere which causes a random value during runtime and is zeroed while under debugger?

[gfunk]

heh, I hate when physics is broken.
maybe the executable code is out of sync? do a full clean rebuild? maybe the wrong dll/debug symbols is being loaded?
maybe there's a background thread running? but that would take some really weird timing.
can you look at the assembly code that is being run? maybe that might give a hint.

[regix]

Thanks for replying,

I have put a qDebug() statement in the method, but that doesn't show up in the output also.
It seems as my code is getting randomly executed. I will check for the variables to see if they are all initialized. About the assemblycode: How does one look at the assemblycode?

Rgx

[wysota]

I have put a qDebug() statement in the method, but that doesn't show up in the output also.

Is the application compiled in debug mode?

[regix]

No, in Release mode with Enable warnings,
should I compile it in Debug mode?

[regix]

I changed the project options in kdevelop to compile in debug mode

g++ -c -pipe -O2 -march=i586 -mtune=i686 -fmessage-length=0 -Wall -D_FORTIFY_SOURCE=2 -g -Wall -W -g -DQT_SHARED -DQT_TABLET_SUPPORT -DQT_NO_DEBUG -DQT_THREAD_SUPPORT -I/usr/lib/qt3/mkspecs/default -I. -I/usr/include/Magick++ -I/usr/include/magick -I/usr/include -I/usr/lib/qt3/include -o dlgtexteffect.o dlgtexteffect.cpp

this is part of the output: it seems to me that NO_DEBUG is still active and the application is still build in release mode??

Rgx

[gfunk]

LOL, I'm surprised you could even step through code in release mode.

[wysota]

this is part of the output: it seems to me that NO_DEBUG is still active and the application is still build in release mode??

If you didn't forget to run qmake after the change in the project file, then it's ok. How does the application behave now? Can you, for example set a breakpoint in the troublesome code and step through it monitoring the behaviour?

[regix]

# File generated by kdevelop's qmake manager. 
# ------------------------------------------- 
# Subdir relative project main directory: ./src
# Target is an application:  
 
LIBS += -lMagick \
        -lMagick++ 
INCLUDEPATH += /usr/include/Magick++ \
               /usr/include/magick 
CONFIG += debug \
          warn_on \
          qt 
TEMPLATE = app 
FORMS += backgrounddlg.ui \
         CreateDialogBase.ui \
         dlgCSS.ui \
         dlgTextEffectBase.ui \
         dlgTextForAllBase.ui \
         EditCSSDlgBase.ui \
         MagickFontDlg.ui \
         ThemeBase.ui \
         websitedialog.ui 
HEADERS += BackGroundDlgImpl.h \
           createdialog.h \
           css.h \
           dlgcssimpl.h \
           dlgtexteffect.h \
           dlgtextforall.h \
           editcssdlg.h \
           htmlgenerator.h \
           htmlpage.h \
           listviewbackground.h \
           magickfontdlgimpl.h \
           mysettings.h \
           myspeciallabel.h \
           mystatuslabel.h \
           saxhandler.h \
           texteffect.h \
           theme.h \
           themeimpl.h \
           thumbnailgenerator.h \
           websitedialogimpl.h 
SOURCES += BackGroundDlgImpl.cpp \
           createdialog.cpp \
           css.cpp \
           dlgcssimpl.cpp \
           dlgtexteffect.cpp \
           dlgtextforall.cpp \
           editcssdlg.cpp \
           htmlgenerator.cpp \
           htmlpage.cpp \
           listviewbackground.cpp \
           magickfontdlgimpl.cpp \
           mysettings.cpp \
           myspeciallabel.cpp \
           mystatuslabel.cpp \
           saxhandler.cpp \
           texteffect.cpp \
           theme.cpp \
           themeimpl.cpp \
           thumbnailgenerator.cpp \
           websitecreator.cpp \
           websitedialogimpl.cpp

# File generated by kdevelop's qmake manager. 
# ------------------------------------------- 
# Subdir relative project main directory: ./src
# Target is an application:  

LIBS += -lMagick \
        -lMagick++ 
INCLUDEPATH += /usr/include/Magick++ \
               /usr/include/magick 
CONFIG += debug \
          warn_on \
          qt 
TEMPLATE = app 
FORMS += backgrounddlg.ui \
         CreateDialogBase.ui \
         dlgCSS.ui \
         dlgTextEffectBase.ui \
         dlgTextForAllBase.ui \
         EditCSSDlgBase.ui \
         MagickFontDlg.ui \
         ThemeBase.ui \
         websitedialog.ui 
HEADERS += BackGroundDlgImpl.h \
           createdialog.h \
           css.h \
           dlgcssimpl.h \
           dlgtexteffect.h \
           dlgtextforall.h \
           editcssdlg.h \
           htmlgenerator.h \
           htmlpage.h \
           listviewbackground.h \
           magickfontdlgimpl.h \
           mysettings.h \
           myspeciallabel.h \
           mystatuslabel.h \
           saxhandler.h \
           texteffect.h \
           theme.h \
           themeimpl.h \
           thumbnailgenerator.h \
           websitedialogimpl.h 
SOURCES += BackGroundDlgImpl.cpp \
           createdialog.cpp \
           css.cpp \
           dlgcssimpl.cpp \
           dlgtexteffect.cpp \
           dlgtextforall.cpp \
           editcssdlg.cpp \
           htmlgenerator.cpp \
           htmlpage.cpp \
           listviewbackground.cpp \
           magickfontdlgimpl.cpp \
           mysettings.cpp \
           myspeciallabel.cpp \
           mystatuslabel.cpp \
           saxhandler.cpp \
           texteffect.cpp \
           theme.cpp \
           themeimpl.cpp \
           thumbnailgenerator.cpp \
           websitecreator.cpp \
           websitedialogimpl.cpp

To copy to clipboard, switch view to plain text mode 

This is my .pro file.
I ran qmake followed by make.
Although debug is marked in the pro file during compilation g++ uses -D NO_DEBUG
I am able to put a breakpoint in the sourcecode but unable to debug it.

Rgx

[regix]

After a second look:

I am actually able to debug the application. It just didnt stop at the second breakpoint. As I can see now several of my bool variables have a numerical value???
I will have a look at the constructor where I give a value to them.

Rgx

[incubator]

I dont understand how that code evne compiles, since when is

if (condition1 and condition2) {}

if (condition1 and condition2) {}

To copy to clipboard, switch view to plain text mode 

valid C++ ?

I thought it should be

if (condition1 && condition2) {}

if (condition1 && condition2) {}

To copy to clipboard, switch view to plain text mode 

[regix]

yes I know, I've tried both and it looks that both compile. The strange thing about my code is: I put a QMessageBox statement in a constructor that gets executed and the code compiles but doesn't get executed. Nothing I change in the code gets executed!!!
It's driving me nuts!

Rgx

[wysota]

Try cleaning your build and rebuilding the application from scratch (make distclean && qmake && make).

[regix]

I have made a new project with kdevelop on a fresh suse 10.0 installation. I imported only the sourcefiles, headers and ui files. I added the config macros and the libs and includes in the pro file, I ran qmake and it issued warnings about possible symbol conflicts in a lot of sourcefiles. I tried to build the project: no luck. I tried to build the subproject (what is the difference between a project and subproject??) and it compiled all the sourcefiles but failed to link the application properly

On the computer where the app is still compiling I ran make distclean in the src directory
It replied no rule to make or something like that probably because I removed all the .o files as well as the moc* files as well as the Makefile. So I ran qmake and in kdev I chose for build project and it compiled and linked fine. When I chose start debug, the application started but jumped over the breakpoint I had put in a constructor that is executed.

????
Rgx

[Big Duck]

perhaps you could try compiling with the -g and -O0, so no optimisations.
This would help when debugging, the lines dont jump around seemingly random.

And then put a watch for the variable so the debugger stops at it, or when it changes.

[regix]

no effect after compiling with O0

Rgx

[wysota]

I have made a new project with kdevelop on a fresh suse 10.0 installation. I imported only the sourcefiles, headers and ui files. I added the config macros and the libs and includes in the pro file, I ran qmake and it issued warnings about possible symbol conflicts in a lot of sourcefiles. I tried to build the project: no luck. I tried to build the subproject (what is the difference between a project and subproject??) and it compiled all the sourcefiles but failed to link the application properly

Did you clean all the temporary files (especially ones that moc created) before moving them to the new project?

[regix]

I went into the src directory and did
rm *.o
rm moc*
rm Makefile

Are there any more files I should delete?

Rgx

[wysota]

Try running 'make clean' or even 'make distclean'.